QotD: “Feminists join men-only swim in protest of proposed law to enable people to self-identify as male or female”

Female activists took a group of male swimmers by surprise on Friday evening when they attended a men-only swim session wearing just trunks and pink swimming caps.

Amy Desir, 30, was one of the two women to gain access to the south London pool session, as part of a protest against proposed changes to the Gender Recognition Act, which would enable men and women to choose their own gender.

Both women explained their attendance to staff at Dulwich Leisure Centre by saying they “identified as male” and subsequently had the right to be there.

Amy Desir: ‘Misogynistic and homophobic pro-self-ID policies are allowing men to appropriate women’s spaces, services and positions’ (Amy Desir)

They also used the male changing rooms before going into the session and were later asked by an elderly man if they realised it was a male-only session.

Their actions form part of a nationwide campaign formed on Mumsnet called #ManFriday which encourages women to “self-identify” as men every Friday in protest of the proposed amendments to gender laws, which would enable people to self-identify as men or women.

“The aim of the group is to raise awareness among men of the misogynistic and homophobic pro-self-ID policies that are allowing men to appropriate women’s spaces, services and positions,” Desir told The Independent.

“Most men either aren’t aware of the issue or don’t think it has anything to do with them.”

There are currently 91 women taking part in #ManFriday, revealed the mother-of-two, all of whom self-ID as men every Friday to access men-only spaces.

“We don’t change anything about our appearance, or pretend to be in the process of transitioning, just state that we are men.”

Desir and her fellow campaigners are concerned that the proposed legislation would enable predatory men to abuse women in single-sex spaces by self-identifying as female.

“We want to challenge the idea that sex and gender are interchangeable and for organisations to use the lawful exemptions in the Equality Act to protect the rights, safety, dignity and privacy of women,” Desir added.

“We also want women’s organisations to be consulted on proposed changes to the law.”

From the Independent

The #ManFriday website is here:

Let’s start with this statement: I am not going to justify women having their own spaces. Thousands of women, some I know, most I don’t, fought the fight for women’s spaces before I was born so that I, and other women in the UK today, don’t have to. Thanks to them, women’s rights, protections, spaces, and services exist to facilitate women’s participation in social life by upholding and protecting our safety, privacy and dignity. Programs and offices reserved for women seek to redress systemic discrimination against women that puts us at a disadvantage compared to our male peers.

(read the whole thing, it’s brilliant!)

If you are a UK citizen, you can sign the government petition here (because it is set up via the UK government, they, in theory, have to take notice; it currently has over 8000 of the 10,000 signatures needed).

The government proposes to amend the law to allow people to self-identify as men or women, and to stop allowing organisations in sensitive situations to exclude people of the opposite birth sex. We call for women to be consulted on how to protect women and girls’ rights, safety, privacy and dignity.

We call for:
– Respectful and evidence-based discussion about the impact of proposed changes and for women’s voices to be heard.

– The government to consult with women’s organisations on how self-declaration would impact on women-only services and spaces, data-gathering, and monitoring of sex-based discrimination.

– The principle of single-sex spaces to be upheld – and where necessary extended.

The Daily Mail has reported on this as well, and this quote towards the end of the article is effectively admitting that this is about letting any man into women’s spaces:

Bernard Reed, a trustee of the Gender Identity Research and Education Society, said: ‘This case demonstrates that women may enter men’s spaces, just as men may enter women’s spaces.

‘Simplifying the current unduly onerous and degrading process of obtaining a gender recognition certificate will just make life easier for trans people.’

In a bizarre (not) case of reversal, tans activists are calling these women sex offenders:

While the response from the Mermaids organisation was unsurprisingly daft:

I also found via tumblr, screen grabs that suggest Swim England’s policy was/is that female bodied persons who identify as male can only swim in binders (which they claim is safe, which I can’t believe) or some other covering – women are not allowed to complain about penises in the women’s changing rooms, but breasts in public are obscene! I can’t currently find this on Swim England’s website, but the colour scheme matches, and I did see a tweet saying Swim England was examining its policy.

To finish, here’s another ManFriday tweet:

4 responses

  1. Reblogged this on Dead Wild Roses and commented:
    Man for a Day, Woot!

  2. Since gender is about identification, I fail to see what’s wrong.

  3. http://manfridayuk.org/2018/03/29/5-rather-educational-weeks/

    5 Rather Educational Weeks

    [Friday 30th March marked] #ManFriday the 5th, and what a hectic 5 weeks it’s been. We’ve been variously:

    – Steeling our brovaries for #randomactsofmanliness
    – Lobbying our MPs and MSPs
    – Writing to public organisations
    – Swimming
    – Testing out the perve-proofedness of the changing rooms in Marks & Spencer, Primark and Topman (clue: they’re really not ready for their self-ID policies)
    – Appearing in local, national and even international newspapers, on the radio and on TV
    – Engaging in debate online and in person
    – Handing out leaflets
    – Encouraging over 8000 people to sign our petition
    – Wearing our #ManFriday badges with pride

    Has it been a success? Yes, it has.

    In 5 weeks we have:

    – Blown apart the #nodebate hashtag that previously dominated the discussion around self-ID;
    – Successfully pushed Swim England to withdraw their deeply flawed Guide to Engaging Trans People in Swimming, which, among other things, told centres that women who complained about men in their changing rooms, toilets, showers and female swimming lessons needed to be re-educated and gas-lighted into accepting that men are really women. Swim England have now opened a public consultation before they publish new guidance. You can bet we’re engaging!
    – Prompted swimming and leisure centres across the country to put into place policies that are trans-friendly as well as protecting women and girls’ legal and lawful right to single-sex facilities; and
    – Proven that self-ID policies are open [to] abuse, leaving women and girls’ rights, safety, privacy and dignity at risk.

    In that time, we have sent pro-self-ID campaigners, eager to replace the objective term ‘sex’ with a misogynistic, lesbo-phobic definition of ‘gender identity’, into something of a tailspin. We’ve been threatened, we’ve been accused of transphobia and we’ve even been accused (falsely and without the slightest basis) of being partially to blame for the murder of a transwoman by a man in a hotel room. These threats and slurs have been accompanied by shocking misogyny, with women being blamed for ‘provoking’ men into murdering them and such murders being dismissed as ‘boring, pedestrian, even accidental’, the result of ‘too much alcohol’, ‘domestic violence “gone wrong”, or women just having thin skulls.

    Let’s be clear here: women are never to blame for male violence. It is never a woman’s fault when a man hits her, rapes her or murders her.

    Let’s be clear again: pointing out the obvious pitfalls of policies and laws that allow men to self-identify as women and then be given access to single-sex rights, services, spaces, posts, protections and programmes is not transphobic. Neither is calling for a free and fair debate around such laws and policies. Neither is demanding that women and girls’ rights, safety, privacy and dignity are upheld.

    We thank our supporters and the organisations who have engaged with us. If you agree with our aims, please do sign the petition at: https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/214118

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: